I Miss Screaming and Fighting
Many have debated the merits on love versus lust in reviewing the strengths and challenges of romantic relationships. Some relationships can feel unforgettable and full of passion and fire, even when they are objectively toxic or unhealthy. A calm and respectful partner can evoke underwhelm or boredom while a turbulent ex can still take up mental and emotional space years later. Some of this passion and tension can be connected to a psychological concept known as limerence.
The term limerence was created by psychologist Dorothy Tennov in the late 1970. It describes an involuntary state of intense romantic obsession. Limerence is characterized by intrusive thoughts, emotional dependency on another person's responses, idealization, and a desperate longing for reciprocation. It can feel like the deepest form of love imaginable and full of fire and passion. However, limerence often has more to do with uncertainty, emotional highs and lows, and the brain's reward system than with genuine intimacy.
One of the most compelling portrayals of this concept appears in Taylor Swift's The Way I Loved You. The song contrasts two relationships: one with a dependable, emotionally available partner and another with a passionate but volatile former love. On the surface, the healthy relationship seems ideal. The new partner is kind, consistent, respectful, and welcomed by family. He communicates well, keeps his promises, and creates emotional safety.
Yet the narrator feels emotionally numb. Instead, she longs for the relationship filled with late-night arguments, dramatic reconciliations, overwhelming passion, and emotional unpredictability. She doesn't necessarily miss the pain itself, she misses the intensity. The emotional roller coaster has become synonymous with love in her mind.
Why Chaos Can Feel Like Chemistry
Limerence thrives on uncertainty.
When affection is inconsistent, our brains often become even more invested. Neuroscience suggests that intermittent reinforcement—the unpredictable alternation between emotional rewards and emotional withdrawal—can strengthen attachment far more powerfully than consistent affection. Every text message, apology, or moment of reconciliation becomes emotionally significant because it isn't guaranteed.
The result is a relationship that feels exhilarating, even addictive.
In contrast, healthy love often lacks these dramatic emotional spikes. Stability doesn't flood the brain with the same cycle of anticipation and relief. It provides something quieter: security, trust, and emotional regulation.
For someone accustomed to emotional turbulence, that quiet can initially feel like boredom.
And I Feel Perfectly Fine
Many people unknowingly equate emotional intensity with emotional depth. The nervous system can associate anxiety with attraction, especially if the earliest experiences of love involved inconsistency, conflict, or emotional unpredictability. Butterflies can become indistinguishable from hypervigilance. Obsession can feel like commitment, emotional exhaustion can feel like passion.
This experience is described in these lyrics:
”But I miss screaming and fighting and kissing in the rain
And it's 2 a.m. and I'm cursing your name
So in love that you act insane
And that's the way I loved you”
The emotions experienced during limerence are genuine. The longing, excitement, hope, and heartbreak are all authentic emotional experiences. What can be misleading is the interpretation. Feeling something intensely doesn't necessarily mean the relationship is healthy, compatible, or sustainable. Sometimes the strongest feelings arise precisely because our emotional needs remain unresolved.
As portrayed in these lyrics:
”And my heart's not breaking
'Cause I'm not feeling anything at all
And you were wild and crazy
Just so frustrating, intoxicating, complicated
Got away by some mistake and now”
Your heart doesn’t have to break for passion or intensity to exist in relationships.
He is Sensible and so Incredible
One of the most difficult transitions people experience after leaving a toxic or emotionally inconsistent relationship is learning to appreciate calm. Healthy love usually is not fueled by uncertainty. It is built on reliability, mutual respect, emotional safety, honest communication, and consistency. The focus is on building connection rather than chasing validation. This emotional steadiness can feel unfamiliar or unsettling at first.
Without dramatic fights followed by euphoric reunions, some people mistakenly conclude that the spark is missing. In reality, what they're missing may be the emotional adrenaline that accompanied uncertainty.
The intensity of limerence is described in these lines:
“Breaking down and coming undone
It's a roller coaster kind of rush
And I never knew I could feel that much
And that's the way I loved you”
Contrasted with a more stable dynamic described here:
”He respects my space
And never makes me wait
And he calls exactly when he says he will
He's close to my mother
Talks business with my father
He's charming and endearing
And I'm comfortable”
Respect and stability don’t have to be boring. It can feel that way if we are used to roller coasters and screaming in the rain, but adjusting to the certainty and stability of a healthy dynamic can be a challenge.
Recognizing limerence is often the first step toward healing. Some important questions for reflection can be:
Am I attracted to this person? Or do I like how they make me feel when they finally choose me?
Do I feel secure in this relationship? Or am I constantly seeking reassurance?
Am I confusing emotional unpredictability with passion?
Would I still want this relationship if the drama disappeared?
Over time, many people discover that real intimacy grows more slowly than limerence. It isn't built on obsession but on trust. It doesn't require emotional chaos to feel meaningful.
The Way I Loved You
Perhaps the most powerful takeaway from songs like The Way I Loved You isn't that chaotic love is better. It's that many of us have been taught to mistake emotional volatility for romance. Recognizing that pattern allows us to rewrite it.
Love doesn't have to feel like surviving a storm.
Sometimes, the healthiest love is the one that lets your nervous system finally rest.
Click Below to learn more about current therapy offerings
